434 N. Fourth Ave.
Started in the 1930s by Caruso himself, this Italian joint has stayed in the same family for four generations. This is probably why the restaurant feels cozy, the food tastes so homemade, and choices are so great. Whether you're looking for an authentic pasta plate, Mediterranean seafood, or a take-out pizza, this is the place to be.
Runners up:
2. Vivace
3. Mama Louisa's
