534 N. Fourth Ave.
Lookin' for a nice, thin slice of Sicilian-style cheese pizza? Brooklyn is there for you. What about a deep dish? Sure, as it's available. Whether you want just a slice or a whole pizza, some classic pepperoni and sausage or some more exotic eggplant, ricotta and potato, this is the type of place that won't just win over a pizza your heart—it will earn the whole thing.
Runners up:
2. Rocco's Little Chicago
3. Empire Pizza